SHOP NOW

It all started on a sunday...

A pizza oven, a batch of homemade bagels, and a few hungry friends turned a Sunday tradition in Andrew’s apartment into sold-out markets and lines wrapped around the block.

Turns out, Oxford really loves bagels.

 OUR STORY ➔

Meet Andrew & Lizzy.

Two people who grew up loving food, started making bagels for their friends, and somehow ended up opening a bagel shop. Here's how it all happened.

 Learn More

Always something in the works.

We're constantly experimenting with new bagel flavors, schmears, and ideas in the kitchen. Keep an eye out for what's coming next.

We're figuring it out as we go.

We're a small business with big plans and a whole lot of bagels to make. Thanks for sticking with us as we grow!

rooted in community

First, it was friends. Then, 150 people showed up at our first market. Now, we have a storefront in Oxford.

The next batch

We're always testing new flavors and schmears. Some make the menu, others send us back to the kitchen.

Our original mascot

Before we had a storefront, we had Remi. Andrew's black lab has been the face of Sunday Bagels since day one.

FRESH INGREDIENTS • MADE FROM SCRATCH

Certified Sourdough

Made with our own sourdough starter, the best ingredients, and lots of love. Every bagel is hand-rolled and baked fresh right here in Oxford, supporting the community that made Sunday Bagels possible.
COME SAY HI →

Frequently asked questions

Do you offer gluten-free bagels?

Sadly, we do not currently have any gluten-free options. We REALLY want to make our bagels more accessible, but right now, we cannot guarantee there will be no cross-contamination in our kitchen!
Are your bagels sesame-free?

We cannot guarantee there will be no cross-contamination with sesame since we use it in our everything bagel seasoning!
Why don't you open earlier than 8 AM?

We would LOVE to open earlier! Everything is handmade, rolled by hand, boiled, and baked in the back. We're pumping out as many bagels as we can before 8 AM and need all the time we can get!
Do you offer catering or pickup orders?

For now, the only way to purchase our bagels is in-store! We would LOVE to cater your events and get bagels to your grove tailgate, but we're focusing on getting production down for our in-store customers first. We hope to change this very soon!!

Subscribe to our emails

Be the first to know about new recipes and special offers!